I read an article recently by Adam B. Kushner in the New York Times (https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/04/briefing/how-to-die.html?smid=url-share) titled “How to Die”. It was about a man, Rajeev Thandani, who distrusted Western Medicine and turned to alternative treatments for his Stage IV lung cancer. He felt like doctors were “crooks” out to make money. Yet he paid tens of thousands of dollars for treatment at clinics offering hydrogen peroxide infusions and coffee enemas. He continued to believe the treatment would work, right up until he died. His daughter, Trisha shared how she struggled with her father’s choices:
“Hope is a delicate thing in the face of a fatal disease: It can give a patient like my dad the will to keep going, but it can also blur easily into false expectations and questionable decisions. It’s a tricky balance that looks different for every patient and family. Instead of chasing an elusive cure, I wish my dad had taken more time to say goodbye and celebrate a life well lived.”
In reading this article, it may be easy to say Mr. Thandani was scammed or tricked into useless treatment for financial gain. However, having worked as a palliative care nurse practitioner for many years, I have seen treatment considered to be the standard of medical care offered to patients whose likelihood of a cure is little to none. Yet they are championed as warriors, bravely “battling” the disease. And they are. They all are. As was the gentleman in this article. In his own way. In a way that held meaning for him.
The question is: when does hope become false, and continued offering of treatment become cruel and exploitative? The answer is not simple. It is different for everyone. Unfortunately, the only opinion some patients hear encourages treatment at all costs, regardless of quality of life or potential outcome. This may be from a genuine optimistic wish that the ever-advancing medical treatment will work, or from unscrupulous financial gain. Some patients believe if they discuss stopping treatment or death, it will make something bad happen, or their doctor will give up on them. The potential remedy? Unhurried conversation about living…and dying. Allowing time to reflect on what a good illness experience may be.
I recently worked with a lovely family. The wife/mother had cancer and did not trust the medical system. She traveled to Mexico for treatments similar to the gentleman in the article. By the time I met her, she was dying...and had spent their life savings. She had never been told her metastatic cancer, with bilateral pulmonary effusions and progressing bowel obstruction was not curable. She continued to have hope…and faith that she would be cured. She adamantly refused to go to the hospital and eventually accepted she was dying. Focus changed from treatment (coffee enemas cannot cure a malignant bowel obstruction) to comfort. She had time with her family. She cried. She prayed. She allowed those she loved to love her through the end of her life. She allowed a natural death, and it was a gift to her family.
There is absolutely a place for encouragement and hope when diagnosed and starting treatment for a serious illness, whatever path or treatment preference one takes. In my years doing this work, I have found the key lies in opening up the conversation…wide. Balancing hope with planning. To stop seeing death as a “failure” or “losing the battle”. Death is as natural as birth. Being human comes with a 100% death rate. Yet we fear it, avoid it. Many doctors and medical providers aren’t comfortable with the idea of dying, so they keep offering hope. Unscrupulous clinicians may avoid discussing death as this limits their profits. Either way, a person with a terminal disease deserves clarity. At some point, without the balance of exploration of what a good death means to the patient and family, hope may be the very source of suffering.